Every year, Mary Morstan receives a pearl in the post from a stranger. She thinks that it has something to do with the disappearance of her father, ten years earlier. But in order to get to the truth, she will need the help of the world’s greatest detective, Sherlock Holmes. In the second of Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes stories, published in 1890, and set two years earlier, Holmes and Watson test their methods on a strange case, involving a mysterious set of four symbols (“the sign of the four”), a hidden treasure stolen from India and then stolen again, and a murder that puzzles everyone. Published at the peak of Britain’s imperialRelating to an empire. power, when London was the centre of the world, the story reflects a fear that the wealth flowing into Britain was bringing danger with it.
The Sign of the Four
Every year, Mary Morstan receives a pearl in the post from a stranger. She thinks that it has something to do with the disappearance of her father, ten years earlier. But in order to get to the truth, she will need the help of the world's greatest detective, Sherlock Holmes. In the second of Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes stories, published in 1890, and set two years earlier, Holmes and Watson test their methods on a strange case, involving a mysterious set of four symbols ("the sign of the four"), a hidden treasure stolen from India and then stolen again, and a murder that puzzles everyone. Published at the peak of Britain's imperialRelating to an empire. power, when London was the centre of the world, the story reflects a fear that the wealth flowing into Britain was bringing danger with it.
Behold Emperor Xi, leader of the modern world
The plot of The Sign of the Four hinges on the British Empire. Captain Morstan, Mary Morstan's father, and Major Sholto served in the Indian army - the army used by the British to rule India. India had been a British colony since 1757, first ruled by a private company, the East India Company, and then directly since 1858. There, it turns out, Sholto betrayed a man named Johnathan Small. He had been imprisoned for murdering an Indian merchant and stealing his treasure. He had buried the treasure and promised to split it with Sholto and Morstan if they went to fetch it for him. When Sholto kept it for himself, Small decided to track them down. He returns to England with the help of an indigenous man from the Andaman island, Tonga. Both Morstan and Sholto are dead, but he still wants his treasure. However, Tonga takes things too far by murdering Bartholomew Sholto, one of the sons of Major Sholto, using an Indian poison. The story reflects an anxiety about the empire. While it brought wealth into Britain, this wealth was taken from the people the British had subjugatedBring under control by defeating. . The novel stages this anxiety by having an Indian man sneak into the house of a Briton who had gained his wealth from colonialism.
Is a new Chinese empire beginning? The Chinese Communist Party will give its leader a historic third term. Experts call it a "coronation" that will affect the whole world.
Is this the wrong time to talk about 'ugly truths'? Thousands are queueing in London to view the Queen lying-in-state - but others are more interested in debating the Royal Family's role in crimes of the past.
Tomorrow it will be 70 years since India gained independence from Britain, and was split into two nations: Muslim-majority Pakistan and Hindu-majority India. What is the legacy of partition?
The Sign of the Four is both a novel about the racism of late VictorianThe era when Queen Victoria was on the British throne, from 1837 to 1901. society and an exhibit of it. This is made clearest in the portrayal of Tonga, the Andamanese man who helps John Small get his revenge. Tonga is able to commit the murder of Bartholomew Sholto because he is short, like most people from his homeland. Holmes solves the case partly by reading a book of racist anthropology and realising that an Andamanese person would be small enough to sneak into the house and murder Thaddeus Sholto. Small himself is patronising towards Tonga, and even uses him as a fairground attraction. On their way back to England, he says, they "earned a living at this time by my exhibiting poor Tonga at fairs and other such places as the black cannibal. He would eat raw meat and dance his war-dance." Small's actions suggest that Victorian Britains treated other races poorly. But the novel also embraces such racist stereotypesStereotypes are ideas about how people will act, based on the group to which they belong.. Johnathan Small, himself, as his name might suggest, has grown more like his "savage" companion. The novel hints that the empire corrupts Britain both because of its immoral plundering of other countries, but also by exposing them to "savage" races. While it is a criticism of the empire, the terms of the criticism are also racist.
Will Britain ever be completely just? The biggest study of racism and inequality in the UK for more than a quarter of a century has produced some shocking statistics.
Can football stop the hate? A talented young player touched the world's heart after he broke down in tears at a press conference, following years of racist abuse.
Is Britain a racist country? The Conservatives' biggest donor is in the spotlight for allegedly making racist remarks - and the party has made things worse by being slow to criticise him.
Justice is an important theme in most detective stories. The Sign of The Four is no exception. Thaddeus Sholto is convinced that an injustice has been done to Mary Morstan because she has been deprived of her share of the treasure. In the letter she takes to Holmes, he writes "you are a wronged woman and you shall have justice". That is why he sends the pearls, and that is why they come to meet him, triggering the events that lead to Holmes solving the murder of Thaddeus' brother Bartholomew. Holmes even lets Small off, because he is convinced that Tonga acted on his own initiative. Small says: "I weltedHit or strike something hard. the little devil with the slack end of the rope for it, but it was done, and I could not undo it again." To the modern reader, and perhaps to many Victorians, the justice of blaming everything on Tonga might not seem clear cut. It is hard to say that justice can ever be served when thinking about imperial plunderTheft..
Is revenge always wrong? A new film explores an Australian dad's secret life as a Nazi hunter. Some look down on all acts of revenge. Others think they work when justice fails.
Solemn days and a furious debate about empire
Could a range of options be more just? The dual-verdict system of "guilty" or "not guilty" is seen as a pillar of many legal systems. But some say we need a new formula for the modern world.
Should there be an age limit to prosecutions? Josef S was 21 when he first became a guard at Sachsenhausen in 1942. He is on trial for assisting in the murder of 3,518 prisoners.
Sherlock Holmes himself is portrayed as a creature of pure reason. We see evidence of his incredible deductiveComing to conclusions through reasoning. skills, including when he is able to recount Watson's brother's sad life story by looking at the key scratches on his pocket watch. But Holmes has no time for emotion. Watson falls in love with Mary Morstan, and Holmes struggles to understand this. As he tells Watson: "Whatever is emotional is opposed to that true cold reason which I place above all things." The question of what matters in life, reason or emotion, becomes part of the story itself, as Watson begins to talk more and more about his feelings for Mary, changing the way the reader experiences the plot. While Holmes is able to explain what has happened, almost all of the action is driven by emotion. Without Thaddeus and his father's guilt, John Small's anger, and Watson's love, there would be no story.
Can a little anxiety be good for us? Pixar's new film shows emotions battling inside a teenager's mind. It has been released as anxiety among young people reaches an all-time high.
Can we know what animals are feeling? Scientists are looking at ingenious ways of exploring other creatures' emotions, with far-reaching implications for how we treat them.
Is noise the key to creativity? Silence helps people think clearly, but the latest research shows noise in the brain may be responsible for extraordinary leaps in imagination.
The main emotion in the story is fear. The Sign of the Four is sometimes called a gothic novel, which means, in part, that it is about fear. The atmosphere of the novel is one in which things are unexplained and scary. Conan Doyle shows that Victorian society runs on fear. Thaddeus and Bartholomew live in fear of having their wealth stolen. Their father employed boxers to protect him and they do the same. The fear of foreigners is everywhere in the novel. Even Holmes, who tries to show that there is nothing to fear because there is nothing that cannot be explained, is afraid that Watson will leave him. He gave a most dismalVery bad. groan. "I feared as much," said he. "I really cannot congratulate you."
Could ghosts really exist? New data shows that an enormous proportion of Americans believe in the paranormal. Scientists and psychologists are scrambling to find an explanation.
Should humanity switch it off? Geoffrey Hinton worked on some of the earliest versions of AI. Now he thinks we are sleepwalking into a global catastrophe that could wipe us out.
Is this terrorism? Days of riots led by far-right groups have targeted mosques and refugees. But there is little agreement on how we should describe the terrible violence.
Keywords
Imperial - Relating to an empire.
Subjugated - Bring under control by defeating.
Victorian - The era when Queen Victoria was on the British throne, from 1837 to 1901.
Stereotypes - Stereotypes are ideas about how people will act, based on the group to which they belong.
Welted - Hit or strike something hard.
Plunder - Theft.
Deductive - Coming to conclusions through reasoning.
Dismal - Very bad.
The Sign of the Four
Glossary
Imperial - Relating to an empire.
Subjugated - Bring under control by defeating.
Victorian - The era when Queen Victoria was on the British throne, from 1837 to 1901.
Stereotypes - Stereotypes are ideas about how people will act, based on the group to which they belong.
Welted - Hit or strike something hard.
Plunder - Theft.
Deductive - Coming to conclusions through reasoning.
Dismal - Very bad.