Critics are split on this timeless classic, which seems to lay teenagehood out on a silver platter. Much like teenagers themselves, the book is divisive. Some enthuse endlessly over its 16-year-old protagonist’s “sensitive genius” and “tragic heroism”, whilst others call it a torture of adolescent whining. It follows an almost stream-of-consciousness subjective monologueA long speech by one person. from the perspective of Holden, its protagonist, as he is expelled from his boarding school, slighted by his love interest and close friend, and caught in skittish adventures in New York City. The adventures include propositioning a prostitute for a reflective conversation, inappropriately haranguing a potentially queer former friend, leading on a “phony” ex, and gravely misinterpreting a paternal gesture from a beloved former teacher. But between these episodes, described alternately as “tedious” and “thrilling”, there is a sweetness that even the most severe critic cannot refute: the teenager’s keen grief from the loss of his brother Allie, his protective love for his younger sister Phoebe, and his desperate conviction that youth should not be corrupted.
The Catcher in the Rye
Critics are split on this timeless classic, which seems to lay teenagehood out on a silver platter. Much like teenagers themselves, the book is divisive. Some enthuse endlessly over its 16-year-old protagonist's "sensitive genius" and "tragic heroism", whilst others call it a torture of adolescent whining. It follows an almost stream-of-consciousness subjective monologueA long speech by one person. from the perspective of Holden, its protagonist, as he is expelled from his boarding school, slighted by his love interest and close friend, and caught in skittish adventures in New York City. The adventures include propositioning a prostitute for a reflective conversation, inappropriately haranguing a potentially queer former friend, leading on a "phony" ex, and gravely misinterpreting a paternal gesture from a beloved former teacher. But between these episodes, described alternately as "tedious" and "thrilling", there is a sweetness that even the most severe critic cannot refute: the teenager's keen grief from the loss of his brother Allie, his protective love for his younger sister Phoebe, and his desperate conviction that youth should not be corrupted.
Teacher's £30,000 for 'love song to youth'
Critics are split between maintaining that Holden has been emotionally and psychologically frozen at the moment of Allie's death years before, rendering him a kind of infant-adolescent, and claiming that he is actually more similar to an adult than to an adolescent. It would be most accurate to say that Holden is teetering on the edge of adulthood, suspended between the two states and not firmly on either side. He is overwhelmed and emotional, much like a teenager - but he is also incisiveAnalytical and clear-thinking. , cynical and intuitive, suggesting a maturity beyond his years. Whilst the protagonists of young adult fiction usually go through some kind of epiphany, Holden remains much the same throughout the novel, with the same fears, attitudes and sensitivities, suggesting that at a minimum he is developing in a non-linear manner.
Should children have more say? Hannah Lowe says that her book is about the wit and wisdom of the kids in her school "who taught me so much". Yet children's views are often dismissed.
Is it time for a new revolutionary age? Hundreds of young people from 30 countries have told researchers they demand a radical transformation in politics, economics and climate action.
Is the teenage brain humanity's greatest mystery? Scientists are beginning to explain the extraordinary physical changes it undergoes - but there is much still to be discovered.
Holden's younger brother, Allie, who died from leukaemiaCancer of the white blood cells. , is a towering character in the book despite his non-presence. One critic describes Allie as "constituting [Holden's] emotional frame of reference", along with his beloved sister Phoebe and his love interest Jane Gallagher (who also never appears physically in the narrative). Holden references Allie often, seeming to be experiencing feelings analogousSomething that is similar to another thing. to survivor's guiltA feeling of guilt for surviving a life-threatening situation whilst others did not. as he reiterates often how far superior his brother was to himself, describing him as "fifty times as intelligent". He is also keen for the reader to understand the greatness of Allie's loss, telling us "you'd have liked him". For many readers, grief is at the core of The Catcher in the Rye, engendering Holden's profound existential shock, hypersensitivity, and feelings of isolation.
Should digital lives have a time limit? Scientists in the US claim they have found a way to create versions of human beings that will survive long after they are dead.
Can the tide of hate be turned? Serious threats to kill politicians, women, scientists and other public figures have soared during Covid. What is going on and can it be stopped?
Is death a single moment? Archie Battersbee's parents and doctors were locked in a legal fight over his life support. The case raises a key question: when does someone really die?
Holden's emotions are punishing, inhibitively strong, and often self-inflicted. His imagination runs wild, creating torturous images of his friend Stradlater canoodling with Jane Gallagher and creating resentment towards people he perceives as "phonies". Many have compared Salinger's protagonist to Shakespeare's Hamlet, an "intuitive moral genius" distinguished for his sentimentalism, paralysing emotional feeling and sense that his emotions isolate him from others.
Are we controlled by unconscious forces?On Bloomsday, people celebrate the life of author James Joyce, who pioneered the radical stream of consciousness writing style.
All change please: Gen Z demands revolution
Do insects have feelings? For decades, the idea that a bug might have emotions was considered absurd - but as the evidence piles up, scientists are rapidly reconsidering.
Do we need more words for happiness? A researcher has been collecting an evolving index of "untranslatable" words related to wellbeing from across the world's languages.
Holden's feelings of isolation pursue him throughout the novel. He alienates himself from some characters, like Sally Hayes and Carl Luce, very deliberately - but for the most part finds himself simply unable to relate to the people around him. The only people he connects with deeply are his dead brother, his unreachable love interest Jane, and his sister Phoebe who, though precociousWhen a child shows mental development or maturity at an unusually young age. , is 10 years old and unlikely to significantly identify with his feelings.
Does being alone mean being lonely? The last surviving member of an uncontacted tribe died in Brazil after 26 years of solitude. But is a life without others really such a bad thing?
Should we all be hermits sometimes? For 40 years Ken Smith lived without electricity in a hand-made log cabin in the Scottish Highlands. Finally his secret is out.
Has Covid unhinged us? From that notorious slap at the Oscars to soaring cases of disruption, experts have noted a surge of antisocial acts. One theory blames the pandemic.
Innocence, and the loss of innocence, are taken by many to be the primary preoccupation of The Catcher in the Rye. They link a lot of Holden's emotional outbursts, from his effusiveGushing or unrestrained gratitude or joy. joy at seeing the childlike Phoebe riding a carousel to his desperate obliteration of an expletive written in graffiti outside Phoebe's school. The central metaphor, Holden's desire to be a "catcher in the rye" who saves children from falling off a cliff edge, is seen by most critics as a metaphor for the baptism of fire into adulthood - a forceful but inevitable loss of innocence. Holden's sympathies also lie with people who retain their innocence and compassion, like Mr Antolini, whom he fondly remembers picking up a boy who had jumped from a window with his own coat, remarking that "he didn't even give a damn if his coat got all bloody." Meanwhile, his dislike of "phonies" springs from a disdain for people who have learned that life is easier when performed, rather than honestly undertaken.
Is Putin lashing out because he is dying? Ukraine's spy chief says his health has sharply declined and that with less than two years to live he is desperate to make his mark.
Is there a link to Fox News? No public figure has promoted "replacement theory" more loudly or relentlessly in America than Tucker Carlson, a host on Rupert Murdoch's TV channel.
Is moral courage stronger than physical force? A photograph of a nun pleading with police in Myanmar not to use violence against demonstrators reminds us of the power of peaceful protest.
Keywords
Monologue - A long speech by one person.
Incisive - Analytical and clear-thinking.
Leukaemia - Cancer of the white blood cells.
Analogous - Something that is similar to another thing.
Survivor's guilt - A feeling of guilt for surviving a life-threatening situation whilst others did not.
Precocious - When a child shows mental development or maturity at an unusually young age.
Effusive - Gushing or unrestrained gratitude or joy.
The Catcher in the Rye
Glossary
Monologue - A long speech by one person.
Incisive - Analytical and clear-thinking.
Leukaemia - Cancer of the white blood cells.
Analogous - Something that is similar to another thing.
Survivor's guilt - A feeling of guilt for surviving a life-threatening situation whilst others did not.
Precocious - When a child shows mental development or maturity at an unusually young age.
Effusive - Gushing or unrestrained gratitude or joy.