Is America censoring free speech? Amid growing concerns about bans on books and drag shows, an anonymous publisher brings grim news from the frontlines of the culture wars.
USA is banning books says secret insider
Is America censoring free speech? Amid growing concerns about bans on books and drag shows, an anonymous publisher brings grim news from the frontlines of the culture wars.
<h2 class="wp-block-heading eplus-wrapper" id="crosshead"><strong>Handle with care</strong></h2>
"I think I am on the wrong side of history with this one... I know I am complicit, I am in the wrong." This might seem like the confession of an unwilling bureaucrat in the machinery of an authoritarianEnforcing strict obedience to authority. state. Instead, it is the anonymous testimony of a publisher in the USA.
The author works for a company that produces books for American schools. She warns that publishers are coming under pressure to conform to increasingly restrictive standards that prevent them from producing certain content.
Publishers are powerless to fight back, she says, because the standards are set by some of the biggest states in the USA, so if they do not conform, they will lose a lot of income from them.
She is worried that she is being forced to take part in censoring books. But she cannot speak about it in public, because she would risk being fired and losing her livelihood.
All in all, her supporters say, it is a grim picture for free speech in 21st Century America. More than 4,000 book bans have been implemented in the USA since July 2021.1 Many of these have targeted books that feature LGBT+ people.
And more restrictive rules are being considered. In FloridaA coastal state in the south-east of the US, between the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico. Though nicknamed "the sunshine state", it also experiences phenomenal rainstorms., new legislation would control the pronounsA word referring to a person and functioning as a noun, such as he/him or she/her. While these are the two most common sets of pronouns, some people prefer non-gendered terms like they/them or xe/xyr. that teachers are allowed to use for children and allow parents to stop school libraries from stocking certain books.
The attack on free speech, they warn, is also moving beyond the classroom. Some states have moved to ban dragPerforming exaggerated forms of gender expression, usually as part of an entertainment act. acts. Campaigners say these laws have the added effect of making it illegal for transgender people to live publicly in the gender with which they identify.
Defenders of these laws say they are not about speech at all: they are about ensuring children do not encounter age-inappropriate content. Putting an "18" label on the film is not censorship, they argue, and neither is sheltering children from content regarding sex and relationships.
Some experts say censorship is not the preserve of the right. They are also worried that the left is seeking to silence those they disagree with.
For example, a proposal in Washington State to set up a hotline allowing people to inform the government about instances of hate speech raised anxieties amongst free speech activists, who warn that it could be used to shut down speech that, while offensive, does not break any laws.
But others think we are having the wrong discussion. They say "free speech" has never really existed, and may not even be a workable concept.
In every society, it is necessary to restrict certain kinds of speech if it will substantially harm others. The classic example is that you cannot be allowed to shout "fire" in a crowded theatre.
The US Constitution enshrines free speech as an individual right. But most individuals do not have the means to make their voices heard: not everyone can have the opportunity to write articles for major newspapers or publish their own books. So most do not have the chance to speak, even if they have the freedom to do so.
Yes: US states are banning books, performances and art, while left-wingers try to get people fired for saying the wrong thing. These are dark times for freedom of expression.
No: People can still write or say whatever they like; they just cannot do it in schools and they cannot say hateful things. On both left and right, this is about protecting vulnerable people, not restricting speech.
Or... While almost everyone agrees that the government should not usually ban speech, there will always be circumstances in which it has to. Truly free speech has never existed and likely would not work.
Authoritarian - Enforcing strict obedience to authority.
Florida - A coastal state in the south-east of the US, between the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico. Though nicknamed "the sunshine state", it also experiences phenomenal rainstorms.
Pronouns - A word referring to a person and functioning as a noun, such as he/him or she/her. While these are the two most common sets of pronouns, some people prefer non-gendered terms like they/them or xe/xyr.
Drag - Performing exaggerated forms of gender expression, usually as part of an entertainment act.
<h5 class="wp-block-heading eplus-wrapper" id="question"><strong>Is America censoring free speech? </strong></h5>
USA is banning books says secret insider

Glossary
Authoritarian - Enforcing strict obedience to authority.
Florida - A coastal state in the south-east of the US, between the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico. Though nicknamed "the sunshine state", it also experiences phenomenal rainstorms.
Pronouns - A word referring to a person and functioning as a noun, such as he/him or she/her. While these are the two most common sets of pronouns, some people prefer non-gendered terms like they/them or xe/xyr.
Drag - Performing exaggerated forms of gender expression, usually as part of an entertainment act.