Are we to blame? The EU holds smugglers responsible for the deadliest Mediterranean shipwreck this year. But critics say "Fortress Europe" forces migrants to risk their lives at sea.
The ship of hope that became a graveyard
Are we to blame? The EU holds smugglers responsible for the deadliest Mediterranean shipwreck this year. But critics say "Fortress Europe" forces migrants to risk their lives at sea.
For tomorrow's World RefugeePeople who are forced from their countries because war or persecution. Day, mourners are reading the names of 51,000 people who have died trying to reach Europe since 1993.1
Last Wednesday that list grew longer when a fishing boat capsized off the Greek coast. Hundreds have drowned.
This is the world's deadliest migration route. People pay smugglers to flee war and poverty in Africa and Asia and many hope to reunite with their families.
For example: the relatives of Shaheen Sheikh Ali from Syria. He knew 12 people on the boat and is furious at the smugglers. They treat us "like meat", he says. "My relatives were only dreaming of coming to Europe to work and help their families."
Nine suspected people traffickersPeople who trade in humans - either as slaves or as migrants being transported in horrific conditions. have been arrested. EUEuropean Union. An economic and political union of 27 countries. commissioner Ylva Johansson says Europe must "dismantleTake apart. the criminal networks" responsible.
But the International Rescue Committee claims migrants have few alternatives. The continent has become a "Fortress Europe" with few "legal pathways" for migrants, they say.
These policies include 1,800km of walls and fences, a €543m (£464m) border patrol and laws that make it a crime to rescue drowning migrants.
"The dead are victims of inequality," says writer Sally Hayden.2 Europe, critics say, has spent centuries exploiting the rest of the world and now wants to keep out those affected by its actions.
The Mediterranean SeaA sea connected to the Atlantic Ocean. It has the shores of Europe on one and the shores of north Africa on the other, as well as shoreline in Asia. is not the main point of entry for refugees. Last year, 4.8 million Ukrainians legally entered the EU to escape the Russian invasion.
"Why not adopt the same policies for Arab and African migrants?" ask economists Klaus F. Zimmermann and Victoria Vernon. Recent research shows Europe needs those migrants to fill vacant jobs.3
But there are 110 million displaced people globally. With climate change, this may rise to 1.2 billion by 2050.4 Whoever is responsible, without urgent action, there will be more disasters like this one.
Are we to blame?
Yes: Europeans must take responsibility for children dying at their gates. Its citizens benefit from a prosperous and safe society and we should use that wealth to make the world more equal and more secure.
No: Traffickers overload their boats with terrified and desperate passengers in order to make the most profit from human suffering. They are ultimately to blame for this tragic loss of life.
Or... We cannot stop migration. And we are far from creating a perfect planet where everyone has everything they need. But we can do much more to prevent people from risking their lives in dangerous boats.
Keywords
Refugee - People who are forced from their countries because war or persecution.
People traffickers - People who trade in humans - either as slaves or as migrants being transported in horrific conditions.
EU - European Union. An economic and political union of 27 countries.
Dismantle - Take apart.
Mediterranean Sea - A sea connected to the Atlantic Ocean. It has the shores of Europe on one and the shores of north Africa on the other, as well as shoreline in Asia.
The ship of hope that became a graveyard
Glossary
Refugee - People who are forced from their countries because war or persecution.
People traffickers - People who trade in humans – either as slaves or as migrants being transported in horrific conditions.
EU - European Union. An economic and political union of 27 countries.
Dismantle - Take apart.
Mediterranean Sea - A sea connected to the Atlantic Ocean. It has the shores of Europe on one and the shores of north Africa on the other, as well as shoreline in Asia.