But was Rome really as gay as that? Ridley Scott’s new epic has historians rolling their eyes. But some think his subversive vision of our ancestors is surprisingly true to life.
The history Gladiator II gets right
But was Rome really as gay as that? Ridley Scott's new epic has historians rolling their eyes. But some think his subversive vision of our ancestors is surprisingly true to life.
He is one of Britain's best-known filmmakers. But at times it can seem like Ridley ScottAn English filmmaker known for his sci-fi, historical and crime films. He was born in 1937. 's life-long purpose is to get the world's historians to tear all their hair out.
Last year there was his blockbuster Napoleon, which experts said was littered with inaccuracies.
Scott did not care: "When I have issues with historians, I ask: Excuse me, mate, were you there?".1
Now his new historical epic Gladiator II, a sequel to the 2000 film, is causing historical consternationA feeling of shock or confusion. It derives from a Latin verb meaning to alarm or dismay. all over again.
At the top of the list of charges: sharks in the ColosseumA vast stadium built by the Roman emperors Vespasian and Titus. It could seat between 50,000 and 80,000 spectators. It was used to hold gladiatorial contests and even mock sea battles. (never happened), rhino-riding (deeply unlikely), and newspaper-reading in a cafe (no newspapers and no cafes in ancient Rome).2
But, whether by accident or design, he does actually get a number of things right about Rome:
Gladiators at sea. The sharks may not be real but the Colosseum was occasionally flooded so gladiators could stage mock sea battles in special flat-bottomed boats.3
Feuding brother rulers. Geta and Caracalla were real and did rule together. But there was no brotherly love lost between them and Caracalla quickly had Geta murdered.
Enslaving prisoners. Many gladiators were prisoners of war, like Lucius Verus.
Black emperor. Denzel WashingtonAn American actor and director born in 1954, seen as one of the best of his generation. 's MacrinusA Roman emperor between 217 and 218AD. character was real, was briefly on the throne and was of North African BerberDescendants of the pre-Arab peoples who lived across North Africa. origin. The Romans had a different idea of race from us and did not believe only those born in Rome could be citizens.
Hints of homosexuality. Same-sex relationships were entirely ordinary in Rome. In fact, for high-born young men, having a relationship with an older man was seen as a useful part of a good education.
Lesbian relationships were more frowned upon, although they were not actually banned.
Was Rome really as gay as that?
Yes: Same-sex relationships were common and even encouraged in Rome. Most modern media brushes over this part of history.
No: While same-sex relationships were common, this does not mean Ancient Rome was a good place to be LGBTStands for lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender. The initialism, as well as some of its common variants, functions as an umbrella term for sexuality and gender identity.+. They mostly involved abuse of younger and lower-status people by powerful men.
Or... There was really no such idea as "gay" in ancient Rome, and to think of it in these terms is anachronisticSomething belonging to the wrong time period.. The conclusion we should draw is that human sexuality is always fluid and open to change across time.
Keywords
Ridley Scott - An English filmmaker known for his sci-fi, historical and crime films. He was born in 1937.
Consternation - A feeling of shock or confusion. It derives from a Latin verb meaning to alarm or dismay.
Colosseum - A vast stadium built by the Roman emperors Vespasian and Titus. It could seat between 50,000 and 80,000 spectators. It was used to hold gladiatorial contests and even mock sea battles.
Denzel Washington - An American actor and director born in 1954, seen as one of the best of his generation.
Macrinus - A Roman emperor between 217 and 218AD.
Berber - Descendants of the pre-Arab peoples who lived across North Africa.
LGBT - Stands for lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender. The initialism, as well as some of its common variants, functions as an umbrella term for sexuality and gender identity.
Anachronistic - Something belonging to the wrong time period.
The history Gladiator II gets right
Glossary
Ridley Scott - An English filmmaker known for his sci-fi, historical and crime films. He was born in 1937.
Consternation - A feeling of shock or confusion. It derives from a Latin verb meaning to alarm or dismay.
Colosseum - A vast stadium built by the Roman emperors Vespasian and Titus. It could seat between 50,000 and 80,000 spectators. It was used to hold gladiatorial contests and even mock sea battles.
Denzel Washington - An American actor and director born in 1954, seen as one of the best of his generation.
Macrinus - A Roman emperor between 217 and 218AD.
Berber - Descendants of the pre-Arab peoples who lived across North Africa.
LGBT - Stands for lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender. The initialism, as well as some of its common variants, functions as an umbrella term for sexuality and gender identity.
Anachronistic - Something belonging to the wrong time period.