Should nature study replace school? The BBC’s Bird Photographer of the Year awards shows the lessons that nature can teach us. Some even say it can teach us all we need to know.
Birds teach the meaning of love says expert
Should nature study replace school? The BBC's Bird Photographer of the Year awards shows the lessons that nature can teach us. Some even say it can teach us all we need to know.
They are birds. But they are all too human. Levi Fitze's photograph of King penguins shows a yellow-necked adult standing firm as its furry brown juvenile appears to beg for food. The adult's eye seems to show a mixture of boredom and resignation.
Fitze is one of the medallists in the Bird Photographer of the Year.1 He faced stiff competition. Antonio Aguti captured a heron swallowing a whole carp. Henley Spiers shot a blue-footed booby diving into a shoalA group of fish swimming together. of sardines. And Nicolas Reusens spied a rare glistening-green tanager delicately stepping out onto a leaf.
The winner was Jack Zhi's dramatic portrait of a peregrine falcon striking down a much larger pelican mid-flight. She did so to protect her young.
Humans often depict nature as an amusing sideshow, to be watched and witnessed. But some think that we can learn a lot from the behaviour of plants and animals. Albert EinsteinA German-born physicist, whose work in the early 20th Century revolutionised scientific understanding of the world. once said: "Look deep into nature, and then you will understand everything better."
One man who agrees is ornithologistAn expert in birds. Noah Strycker. Strycker has seen more birds than almost anyone else.2 In his book The Magic and Mystery of Birds, he examines the many parallels between us and our avianTo do with birds. friends.
Strycker shows the lessons birds can teach us. He explores how American nutcrackers bury seeds for the winter in thousands of tiny troves. He looks at the Australian fairy-wrens, who look after each other's children as one big family.
And he describes the incredible albatross, which can fly up to 2,000 miles to pick up food for their children. Albatrosses mate for life. He writes: "I think albatrosses feel love even more intensely than we do."
Humans have long loved birds. Several indigenous American peoples believed a raven created the world. The mediaeval emperor Frederick II wrote a treatiseA written work formally addressing a subject. about capturing and training falcons. And pigeons have been taught to carry messages. This made them valuable allies in both world wars.
They have been a source of creative inspiration, from Attar of Nishapur's Persian poem The Conference of the Birds (1177) to John KeatsAn English Romantic poet who died in 1821 aged 25 from tuberculosis. ' Ode to a Nightingale (1819), where a bird inspires thoughts on life and death. And in JA Baker's remarkable book The Peregrine (1967), the author even seems to want to become a bird.
Love, parenting, communication, even mortalityThings that can die are mortal. : it seems there are few things birds cannot teach us. Who needs school when we can learn from nature?
Yet some think that nature cannot teach us everything we need. We can do dozens of things as humans that no other animal can do, whether speaking, reading books or writing computer code. Simply watching nature will not teach us any of these things.
And not all lessons nature offers are good ones. Philosopher John Stuart MillA 19th-Century English philosopher who wrote extensively about freedom and democracy. He is regarded as the father of modern liberalism. believed that "Nature is cruel and thoughtless." Animal life is one of many violent acts, from fighting over mates to hunting down prey. People who learn only from nature might become brutal to others.
Should nature study replace school?
Yes: Sack all the teachers. Nature tells us how to find food, how to build shelters, how to behave to others. If we spent more time copying nature, the world would be cleaner, greener and more sustainable.
No: Nature study is wonderful. But it is limited. Nature is silent on laws and ethics, history and technology, literature and languages. And it is these things which make us truly human, more than animal.
Or... There is no reason we should not have both. Schools can help us learn about nature. Studying the collected wisdom of biologists, for instance, can enhance our understanding of the animals we observe.
Keywords
Shoal - A group of fish swimming together.
Albert Einstein - A German-born physicist, whose work in the early 20th Century revolutionised scientific understanding of the world.
Ornithologist - An expert in birds.
Avian - To do with birds.
Treatise - A written work formally addressing a subject.
John Keats - An English Romantic poet who died in 1821 aged 25 from tuberculosis.
Mortality - Things that can die are mortal.
John Stuart Mill - A 19th-Century English philosopher who wrote extensively about freedom and democracy. He is regarded as the father of modern liberalism.
Birds teach the meaning of love says expert
Glossary
Shoal - A group of fish swimming together.
Albert Einstein - A German-born physicist, whose work in the early 20th Century revolutionised scientific understanding of the world.
Ornithologist - An expert in birds.
Avian - To do with birds.
Treatise - A written work formally addressing a subject.
John Keats - An English Romantic poet who died in 1821 aged 25 from tuberculosis.
Mortality - Things that can die are mortal.
John Stuart Mill - A 19th-Century English philosopher who wrote extensively about freedom and democracy. He is regarded as the father of modern liberalism.