Have we got it all wrong? A Western mother who took her baby to live in the Ecuadorian jungle found her ideas about how to be a parent turned upside down by local people.
Babies prefer Amazon childcare says expert
Have we got it all wrong? A Western mother who took her baby to live in the Ecuadorian jungle found her ideas about how to be a parent turned upside down by local people.
The baby was sitting with his mother when Leticia picked him up. "Poor little baby, what will you do if your mother dies?" she asked. "You will be an orphan! Alone and sad!" Then she turned around so that mother and child could not see each other. "Look! There is no more Mama! She is gone, dead! What will you do, my dear?"
This scene is described by the mother, Francesca Mezzenzana, in an article for Aeon. It was part of an experience that transformed her views on bringing up children.
Francesca is an anthropologistSomeone who studies human beings and societies. The word "anthropology" comes from the Greek "anthropos", meaning "human". It developed as a subject in Europe in the 19th century, although some regard the Arab historian Ibn Khaldun as the first anthropologist.. When her baby was four months old, she and her EcuadorianEcuador is a South American country with a population of nearly 18 million. husband took him to live in a village on the Amazon which was home to 500 Runa people.
Francesca arrived with all the ideas about being a parent that are accepted in the West. But these seemed strange to the Runa.
One thing that worried them was the way Francesca carried her baby - in a sling facing towards her, so that he was always aware of her comforting presence. Runa babies are also carried in a sling, and accompany their parents day and night - but facing outwards.
Francesca realised that whereas she thought children needed protection and should be looked after by their parents, the Runa thought that they should engage with the world and be cared for by the whole community.
This was the point that Leticia had been making: a child should not be entirely dependentRelying on someone or something. on his or her mother. Francesca needed to get used to the idea of another villager taking her baby off for hours or even days to give her a break.
Another belief Francesca brought with her was that children should be the main focus of their parents' attention. Everything the family does should be geared to them.
But in Runa society, she found, "No canoe trip under a merciless sun is modified... No meal is organised around the needs of a young child. Parents do not play with their children."
This is not to say that Runa parents are less loving than Western ones. Rather, they want their children to grow up as happy and useful members of a close-knit community.
Children are taught from an early age that the world does not just revolve around them: they need to think about other people's wants and needs. That involves helping around the house and looking after younger children as soon as they are old enough to.
Have we got it all wrong?
Yes: Western parents are much too indulgent towards their children. This increases the risk of them growing up as spoilt, selfish individualists. The Runa's community approach is far healthier.
No: Children are very vulnerable and need constant attention and encouragement if they are to grow up well-adjusted and successful - particularly in an environment as competitive as Western society.
Or... There is no "right" way to bring up a child. Different communities require different qualities in their members. If Runa parents took their children to the West, they would adapt their ways too.
Keywords
Anthropologist - Someone who studies human beings and societies. The word "anthropology" comes from the Greek "anthropos", meaning "human". It developed as a subject in Europe in the 19th century, although some regard the Arab historian Ibn Khaldun as the first anthropologist.
Ecuadorian - Ecuador is a South American country with a population of nearly 18 million.
Dependent - Relying on someone or something.
Babies prefer Amazon childcare says expert
Glossary
Anthropologist - Someone who studies human beings and societies. The word "anthropology" comes from the Greek "anthropos", meaning "human". It developed as a subject in Europe in the 19th century, although some regard the Arab historian Ibn Khaldun as the first anthropologist.
Ecuadorian - Ecuador is a South American country with a population of nearly 18 million.
Dependent - Relying on someone or something.