Are we taking Taylor Swift too seriously? Academics have gathered in Melbourne to discuss the world-conquering pop star. Some think she should remain in the tabloids.
Academics meet to study 'godlike superstar'
Are we taking Taylor Swift too seriously? Academics have gathered in Melbourne to discuss the world-conquering pop star. Some think she should remain in the tabloids.
Taylormania
It is becoming hard to spend a day without hearing, reading about or seeing a picture of Taylor Swift.
The country-pop star is everywhere: touring the world, rerecording albums, winning GrammysThe most prestigious award in the US music industry. The trophy is shaped like a gilded gramophone. Last year, Billie Eilish won most of the main awards.. She has even conquered sport, regularly appearing at American football games to support her boyfriend Travis Kelce.
But her latest conquest is far from the glamour of stadiums. As Swift attended the Super BowlAn American football match played each year to decide which team is the best in the country. , the University of MelbourneThe capital of the state of Victoria, and Australia's second largest city after Sydney. opened its Swiftposium, a three-day academic conference devoted to discussing her cultural influence.
It was originally intended to be a small event, held in two rooms. But Swift's popularity caused it to swell to 130 speakers across 60 subjects. Academics discussed Swift in the context of the music industry, gender, law, literature, sports, economics,1 pop culture, CPRShort for cardiopulmonary resuscitation. An emergency procedure that is used to save someone's life if their breathing or heart stops. training - and much more.
Many of the speakers are fans. But they were not uncritical. One report looked at how Swift sings about public transport while flying in her carbon-belching private jet.2 Others explored her music's relationship to race and colonialismThis refers not only to the material realities of colonial rule, but also to the mindset of the colonising powers and their ways of justifying empire. Most Europeans believed that empire was a moral good, because it imparted 'civilisation' to 'primitive' cultures and so helped them to develop..
Organiser Dr Emma Whatman says: "Celebrity culture holds a mirror up to society. It shapes the conversations we have about gender, race and the environment."
Swift's influence is undeniably vast. Time magazine named her Person of 2023.3 Her tour is record-breaking.4 At one concert her fans cheered so much they generated seismicOf enormous size or effect. activity similar to a magnitude 2.3 earthquake.
Swift is especially important because her songs tell young women that their thoughts have value. Girls' and women's concerns have often been dismissed as unserious. "For people conditioned to believe that their interior lives don't matter," writes journalist Sian Cain, "it's powerful to be told that they actually really, really do."
Yet we might be taking Taylor Swift too seriously. "Fame," wrote the poet Emily Dickinson, "is a fickle food upon a shifting plate." Dickinson would know. She was little known in life. But after her death she became known as one of America's greatest poets. Her then-popular contemporaries were forgotten. The same fate might await Swift.
Are we taking Taylor Swift too seriously?
Yes: Swift is a powerful figure. But our focus on her ignores dozens of musicians, artists and activists whose work is having a similar effect on the world. Study Swift - but study others as well.
No: Swift is a global success. She might have more impact on peoples' listening, lives and thoughts than any musician in history. We should not underestimate the global impact of her life and work.
Or... We might be taking Swift and her music too seriously. But the world that has developed around her - the gossip, the tours, the fandom, the column inches - is central to our culture.
Keywords
Grammys - The most prestigious award in the US music industry. The trophy is shaped like a gilded gramophone. Last year, Billie Eilish won most of the main awards.
Super Bowl - An American football match played each year to decide which team is the best in the country.
Melbourne - The capital of the state of Victoria, and Australia's second largest city after Sydney.
CPR - Short for cardiopulmonary resuscitation. An emergency procedure that is used to save someone's life if their breathing or heart stops.
Colonialism - This refers not only to the material realities of colonial rule, but also to the mindset of the colonising powers and their ways of justifying empire. Most Europeans believed that empire was a moral good, because it imparted 'civilisation' to 'primitive' cultures and so helped them to develop.
Seismic - Of enormous size or effect.
Academics meet to study ‘godlike superstar’
Glossary
Grammys - The most prestigious award in the US music industry. The trophy is shaped like a gilded gramophone. Last year, Billie Eilish won most of the main awards.
Super Bowl - An American football match played each year to decide which team is the best in the country.
Melbourne - The capital of the state of Victoria, and Australia’s second largest city after Sydney.
CPR - Short for cardiopulmonary resuscitation. An emergency procedure that is used to save someone's life if their breathing or heart stops.
Colonialism - This refers not only to the material realities of colonial rule, but also to the mindset of the colonising powers and their ways of justifying empire. Most Europeans believed that empire was a moral good, because it imparted 'civilisation' to 'primitive' cultures and so helped them to develop.
Seismic - Of enormous size or effect.