Do we all need therapy? Darth Vader may have had borderline personality disorder, say researchers. But could everyone – both fictional and real – benefit from talking through their problems?
Therapists say even Darth Vader could be nice
Do we all need therapy? Darth Vader may have had borderline personality disorder, say researchers. But could everyone - both fictional and real - benefit from talking through their problems?
He is one of cinema's most iconic villains.
A masked bully who wields the Force In the Star Wars universe, it is an energy that flows through all living things and allows the Jedi, their enemies, and the Sith to read minds, move objects from afar, and see into the future. to intimidate and overcome his rivals, Darth Vader is the face of evil in the Star Wars saga.
As a young Jedi called Anakin Skywalker, he is presented as a gifted but troubled youth who gives in far too easily to his negative emotions.
But, perhaps, his story is better understood through the lens of modern psychiatryThe medical application of psychology devoted to the diagnosis, prevention, and treatment of mental disorders..
According to researchers, Anakin, later Lord Vader, displays many of the traits commonly associated with borderline personality disorderA condition of mood and how a person interacts with others. It is the most commonly recognised personality disorder. (BPD).
In a serious academic paper, Eric Bui and his team write: "The character fulfilled six of the nine borderline personality disorder (BPD) criteria. He presented impulsivity and difficulty controlling his anger and alternated between idealisation and devaluation1."
Borderline personality disorder is a mental health condition characterised by emotional instability, regular delusions, and extremely intense relationships with other people.
As well as betraying the entire Jedi order in order to quellTo put an end to (a rebellion or other disorder), typically by the use of force. a bad dream about his wife, he murders fellow generals and cannot understand why his son Luke Skywalker does not want to join him in ruling the galaxy after he chops off his hand.
Experts say that using the modern language of mental health helps us to understand fictional characters.
Darth Vader is not alone in needing help for his mental health. Elsa, from the Disney film Frozen, is another who could be suffering from BPD. She struggles to stay on top of the emotional outbursts that negatively affect those around her.
Though still poorly understood, BPD is thought to affect around 2% of the population. "I believe that psychotherapy would have helped Anakin and might have prevented him from turning to the dark side," says Bui.
But it is not just people - or characters - with diagnosed mental health conditions that can benefit from therapy, claim some experts.
"Who wouldn't benefit from meeting with a professional listener/problem solver once per week to take stock of their life and work on reducing struggle or attaining personal potential and life satisfaction?" asks psychotherapist Ryan Hows.
"I'd like to meet that person."
Do we all need therapy?
Yes: If therapy can help Darth Vader, it can help anyone. And even for people with no mental health issues, therapy can boost your emotional wellbeing and help you through difficult days.
No: Everyone loves a villain, and Darth Vader is one of the most popular. We do not need or want everyone in life to become a saint. Psychotherapy is not always the answer.
Or... The way to convince people to try therapy is not by diagnosing fictional characters with mental health conditions. It is stigmatisingDisapproving of, or discriminating against, a person based on perceivable characteristics. It's the opposite of respecting and recognising someone or something, especially when it comes to mental health conditions. to compare an intergalactic supervillain to real-life people.
Keywords
The Force - In the Star Wars universe, it is an energy that flows through all living things and allows the Jedi, their enemies, and the Sith to read minds, move objects from afar, and see into the future.
Psychiatry - The medical application of psychology devoted to the diagnosis, prevention, and treatment of mental disorders.
Borderline personality disorder - A condition of mood and how a person interacts with others. It is the most commonly recognised personality disorder.
Quell - To put an end to (a rebellion or other disorder), typically by the use of force.
Stigmatising - Disapproving of, or discriminating against, a person based on perceivable characteristics. It's the opposite of respecting and recognising someone or something, especially when it comes to mental health conditions.
Therapists say even Darth Vader could be nice
Glossary
The Force - In the Star Wars universe, it is an energy that flows through all living things and allows the Jedi, their enemies, and the Sith to read minds, move objects from afar, and see into the future.
Psychiatry - The medical application of psychology devoted to the diagnosis, prevention, and treatment of mental disorders.
Borderline personality disorder - A condition of mood and how a person interacts with others. It is the most commonly recognised personality disorder.
Quell - To put an end to (a rebellion or other disorder), typically by the use of force.
Stigmatising - Disapproving of, or discriminating against, a person based on perceivable characteristics. It’s the opposite of respecting and recognising someone or something, especially when it comes to mental health conditions.