Are we losing more than words? Linguists say the world’s minority languages are going through a mass extinction event. This may make communication easier. But what else is lost?
The woman whose death is the end of a world
Are we losing more than words? Linguists say the world's minority languages are going through a mass extinction event. This may make communication easier. But what else is lost?
You meet someone and share a deep meaningful gaze. Both of you want to say something but are afraid to do so. This moment is called mamihlapinatapaiThere have been several attempts to translate this Yamana word. For example: "A look shared by two people, each wishing that the other would initiate something that they both desire but which neither wants to begin.". It is the world's "most succinct wordThe Guinness Book of Records considers it the most difficult word to translate briefly into English." and belongs to the South American language of Yamana.
This year, Yamana became extinct. On an island in the far south of Chile, 93-year-old Cristina Calderon died. Since she lost her sister in 2003, she has been the only member of the Yagan community still speaking their native tongue.
It is a reminder that languages can die. Every year, the world marks International Mother Language Day, a celebration of linguistic diversity. It began in Bangladesh to remember five protesters killed on 21 February 1952, defending their right to speak BengaliThe sixth most-spoken language in the world. In 1952, Bangladesh was part of Pakistan and the government tried to impose Urdu as the national language..
The world is losing languages at an alarming rate. Around 400 disappeared last century and half of the remaining 6,500 may be gone by 2100. Every fortnight, on average, another falls silent.
Yamana is an "isolate" - unrelated to all other languages. But for the Yagan people, they have lost more than words. As Calderon's daughter says: "an important part of the cultural memory of our people is gone."
Many linguists argue language influences how we think and see the world. And Yamana is also a store of ancient knowledge about the landscape, wildlife and culture of the region. Moreover, for many indigenous people, language is an essential part of their identity.
This is not just about the past, says linguist David Harrison. "No culture has a monopoly on human genius, and we never know where the next brilliant idea may come from." Language is stored wisdom humanity cannot afford to lose.
Calderon's children were the first generation to grow up speaking Spanish. World languagesGlobal languages that allow people from many different countries to communicate. For example English, Spanish, Arabic and French. offer more opportunities for education and work. So if language is for communication, some people think it would be better if we all used the same one.
According to the Bible, humans spoke one language until God punished them for building the Tower of BabelThey wanted to build a tower that reached up to heaven. It was named Babel (Hebrew, balal, to confuse) because God created a "confusion" of languages.. Throughout history, languages have been the lingua francaFor example, Latin was the common language of the Roman Empire, French was the language of the European aristocracy and English has become the working language of international finance. of culture, business and diplomacy. There have even been attempts to create a universal language, like EsperantoIn English, one who hopes. Constructed in 1887 with simplified grammar to make it quicker to learn. There are around 100,000 Esperanto speakers., to unite nations in "common brotherhood".
English has close to 200,000 words, more than any other language. But this does not mean it is more sophisticated than unwritten vernacular with smaller vocabularies. "Most have incredibly complex grammatical systems that far exceed that of English," says anthropologist Mark Turin.
Two-thirds of languages are not written down. So it is a race against time to record their words, stories and songs before the last speaker dies. Once gone, it is rare for languages to come back. Hebrew is the only tongue to return from the dead.
There is no word for goodbye in CherokeeA native language of the Cherokee people of North America., only: "I will see you again." With fewer than 2,000 speakers, it too is endangered. For some, its fate is inevitable. But others think these languages can and must survive.
Are we losing more than words?
Yes: Languages are worlds of experience and wisdom. No word is fully translatable because it expresses something unique about its culture and the people who use it. Each language enriches our world.
No: This is sentimental, languages are not people. They are tools for communication and cooperation. If we all spoke the same tongue, there would be more understanding and less conflict.
Or... It is sad, but we should not confuse the death of a language with its culture. Spanish-speaking Yagans continue to celebrate their culture and Yamana has given the world the word mamihlapinatapai.
Keywords
Mamihlapinatapai - There have been several attempts to translate this Yamana word. For example: "A look shared by two people, each wishing that the other would initiate something that they both desire but which neither wants to begin."
Most succinct word - The Guinness Book of Records considers it the most difficult word to translate briefly into English.
Bengali - The sixth most-spoken language in the world. In 1952, Bangladesh was part of Pakistan and the government tried to impose Urdu as the national language.
World languages - Global languages that allow people from many different countries to communicate. For example English, Spanish, Arabic and French.
Tower of Babel - They wanted to build a tower that reached up to heaven. It was named Babel (Hebrew, balal, to confuse) because God created a "confusion" of languages.
Lingua franca - For example, Latin was the common language of the Roman Empire, French was the language of the European aristocracy and English has become the working language of international finance.
Esperanto - In English, one who hopes. Constructed in 1887 with simplified grammar to make it quicker to learn. There are around 100,000 Esperanto speakers.
Cherokee - A native language of the Cherokee people of North America.
The woman whose death is the end of a world
![](https://theday.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/2022-02-21_languages.jpg)
Glossary
Mamihlapinatapai - There have been several attempts to translate this Yamana word. For example: "A look shared by two people, each wishing that the other would initiate something that they both desire but which neither wants to begin."
Most succinct word - The Guinness Book of Records considers it the most difficult word to translate briefly into English.
Bengali - The sixth most-spoken language in the world. In 1952, Bangladesh was part of Pakistan and the government tried to impose Urdu as the national language.
World languages - Global languages that allow people from many different countries to communicate. For example English, Spanish, Arabic and French.
Tower of Babel - They wanted to build a tower that reached up to heaven. It was named Babel (Hebrew, bālal, to confuse) because God created a "confusion" of languages.
Lingua franca - For example, Latin was the common language of the Roman Empire, French was the language of the European aristocracy and English has become the working language of international finance.
Esperanto - In English, one who hopes. Constructed in 1887 with simplified grammar to make it quicker to learn. There are around 100,000 Esperanto speakers.
Cherokee - A native language of the Cherokee people of North America.