Do we need a new story? We are used to tales of doom and gloom on climate issues. Now, one eminent writer says we need to talk about the good news too — or risk falling into indifference and despair.
'The climate crisis is an imagination crisis'
Do we need a new story? We are used to tales of doom and gloom on climate issues. Now, one eminent writer says we need to talk about the good news too - or risk falling into indifference and despair.
Hurricanes in Cuba. Droughts in Europe. Floods in Pakistan. A recovery bill reaching into the tens of billions of dollars. These are but a few of the climate related disasters that swept the world in 2022. Most expect the same story to be told in 2023 - and 2024, 2025 and countless years to come.
But is this story the wrong story? Is it as compelling as it once was? Or are people starting to suffer from climate change fatigueTiredness.?
We are attracted to grim narratives. Stories of climate catastrophe make the headlines far more often than stories of innovation or renewal. Now, American writer Rebecca Solnit argues that we need to reframe our arguments if we are to motivate people to address climate change.
The importance of storytelling in shaping public understanding of climate change cannot be understated. The way in which the issue is framed can greatly influence how people respond to it. If the dominant story about climate change is one of doom and despair, Solnit writes, it will discourage people from taking action. However, if the story is one of hope and possibility, it will inspire people to take bold and meaningful action.
Solnit argues that we need to stop talking about the climate apocalypse, stop talking about individual wrongdoing and start exposing those really responsible for climate chaos.
There is no doubt: climate action needs to happen quickly. But there are still reasons to be optimistic. COP27The 2022 United Nations Climate Change Conference, known as the Conference of the Parties (COP). showed that many countries are committed to reaching net-zero emissions by 2050 and transitioning to a cleaner future.
Many individuals and organisations are working tirelessly to address the issue of climate change. And people all over the world are taking steps to reduce their carbon footprint and promote sustainable practices.
There has been a big push for people to take individual action over climate change. We are told we must travel less and recycle more. But the truth, climate activists point out, is that the carbon footprintThe total amount of greenhouse gases (including carbon dioxide and methane) that are generated by our actions. China is the top emitter with 28% of the world's total emissions. The US is second with 14%. of the richest 1% in society is twice that of the poorest 50%.
This means that the story of climate change also needs to be reframed to prioritise the voices of those who are most affected by it. This includes the low-income nations who are disproportionately impacted by the effects of climate change, yet often have little say in the decisions that affect their lives.
Whilst trying to combat climate change is a laudableSomething to be praised. aim, campaigners say that the difference individuals will make by cutting down on luxuries is negligibleVery little or almost nothing.. Rather, the power people do have is to unite as citizens and demand better from national governments.
This is where imagination comes in - by imagining new ways to live and consume, new technologies, new forms of governance and new economic models that will help to reduce our carbon footprint and adapt to the changing climate.
"There's no single answer that will solve all of our future problems," declared the American author Octavia E ButlerAn African American author known for her award-winning sci fi novels. . "There's no magic bullet. Instead there are thousands of answers - at least. You can be one of them if you choose to be."
Do we need a new story?
Yes: Addressing the climate crisis is not only a technical or scientific challenge, but also one that requires imagination. We need new ways of thinking and new stories that can inspire and mobilise people to take action.
No: As long as we base our stories on scientific fact there is no need to change them. The possibility of climate disaster is very real and we need people to realise that.
Or... A balance needs to be found. People must understand the urgency required to avert climate chaos - but also realise that we are making progress. Too much doom and gloom will help no one.
Keywords
Fatigue - Tiredness.
COP27 - The 2022 United Nations Climate Change Conference, known as the Conference of the Parties (COP).
Carbon footprint - The total amount of greenhouse gases (including carbon dioxide and methane) that are generated by our actions. China is the top emitter with 28% of the world's total emissions. The US is second with 14%.
Laudable - Something to be praised.
Negligible - Very little or almost nothing.
Octavia E Butler - An African American author known for her award-winning sci fi novels.
‘The climate crisis is an imagination crisis’
Glossary
Fatigue - Tiredness.
COP27 - The 2022 United Nations Climate Change Conference, known as the Conference of the Parties (COP).
Carbon footprint - The total amount of greenhouse gases (including carbon dioxide and methane) that are generated by our actions. China is the top emitter with 28% of the world’s total emissions. The US is second with 14%.
Laudable - Something to be praised.
Negligible - Very little or almost nothing.
Octavia E Butler - An African American author known for her award-winning sci fi novels.