‘The most ghastly disaster of the whole war’

Classic: A still from the famous opening sequence of the D-Day epic, Saving Private Ryan.

Was D-Day more of an epic human tragedy than a military triumph? Tomorrow, Donald Trump and the Queen will lead the world in marking the 75th anniversary of a famous Allied victory.

Almost exactly 75 years ago, on 6 June 1944, the largest seaborne invasion force in history landed on the beaches of Normandy.

Even before the landing started, hundreds of paratroopers, dropped behind the lines, had drowned in the flooded fields.

The Allied bombers missed most of the German shore defences, and the invasion force initially failed to reach any of the major objectives set for the assault, even though the defenders had anticipated the landing to take place elsewhere.

Allied casualties in battle were not significantly lower than those of the German defenders — despite the fact that most German army units in France were made up of child soldiers forcibly drafted into fight, and deaf war invalids from the Eastern Front.

Nearly 20,000 French civilians were killed in Normandy alone during and immediately after the landing, most of them as a result of misguided Allied bombing attacks that failed to destroy German defensive positions, but hit civilian dwellings instead.

By the end of the campaign, 50,000 French civilians had died — a death toll that exceeded that of the actual combatants.

Antony Beevor, the British historian, has called the RAF’s bombing of Caen, which destroyed the entire city except for the German defensive positions, “stupid, counterproductive and, above all, very close to a war crime”.

Allied commanders were deeply pessimistic. On the eve of the invasion, Field Marshal Sir Alan Brooke confided, “It may well be the most ghastly disaster of the whole war.”

The supreme Allied commander, General Eisenhower, prepared a provisional press release announcing that “the landings in the Cherbourg-Havre area have failed”.

And yet, measured against these grim expectations, D-Day proved to be a great military success.

The operation began the liberation of German-occupied France, and later Europe, from Nazi control — and laid the foundations of the Allied victory on the Western Front.

To land 70,000 soldiers under enemy fire, within a few hours, was a remarkable strategic achievement.

From the shores of occupied France, the German defenders watched the approaching fleet with a combination of awe and horror.

To one of the Wehrmacht soldiers guarding the French coastline, the approaching 7,000 vessels looked like “a gigantic town on the sea” unleashing a naval bombardment “like an earthquake”.

The story has been told thousands of times, notably by Stephen Spielberg in his 1998 blockbuster movie Saving Private Ryan. (The film has been re-released for this anniversary.)

The long opening sequence of the beach landings has been called “probably the most realistic battle sequence ever filmed”. Yet many critics have also questioned its attempt to rediscover American innocence with a climax that combines “just about every cliché in the book”.

T-Day?

Tomorrow’s commemoration, led by the Queen and Trump, will offer thanks and honour to the many who died in battle. It will not shy away from the horrific realities of war. But it is also inevitable that it will present D-Day as a strategic triumph that forged the alliances, guaranteeing generations of future peace and stability for the western world.

Surely it is now time to be more honest, say the critics. Like all war, D-Day was a mess and a disaster. Sir Alan Brooke was righter than he thought. And what we are witnessing tomorrow is really T-Day or Trump Day — the might of one huge, ego-driven economic power, the USA, basking in the obeisance of its former imperial partner, Britain.

You Decide

  1. Should all war commemorations be a form of mourning?
  2. Is war a necessary precursor to peace?

Activities

  1. Draw a timeline of D-Day, of what happened when, during the 24 hours of 6 June 1944.
  2. Imagine you are a German soldier in Normandy. Write a letter home about your experience of D-Day. Make it very personal and descriptive (using sensory and emotive langauge), in a tone that you might address your family.

Some People Say...

“At this historic moment, surely not one of us is too busy, too young, or too old to play a part in a nation-wide, perchance a world-wide vigil of prayer as the great crusade sets forth.”

King George VI (radio address, 6 June 1944)

What do you think?

Q & A

What do we know?
German casualties on D-Day have been estimated at 4,000 to 9,000 men. Allied casualties were at least 10,000, with 4,414 confirmed dead. Between 15,000 and 20,000 French civilians were killed during the wider Normandy Campaign, although many more fled their homes to escape the main combat area.
What do we not know?
What might have happened if D-Day had failed. “I think the Soviets could have won the war single-handedly, perhaps by 1946. I think we may well have seen the hammer and sickle flying not simply in Poland and Eastern Germany, but in Western Germany, the Benelux countries and France,” says the military historian, Professor Gary Sheffield.

Word Watch

Allied
The big four Allied powers of World War Two were England (GB, the United Kingdom), the USA, the Soviet Union (USSR, Russia), and France. But it is important to remember other allies included: Australia, Belgium, Bolivia, Brazil, Canada, China, Denmark, Greece, Mexico, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, South Africa and Yugoslavia.
Eastern Front.
The war on the Eastern Front, known to Russians as the “Great Patriotic War”, was the scene of the largest military confrontation in history. Over the course of four years, more than 400 Red Army and German divisions clashed in a series of operations along a front that extended more than 1,000 miles.
Caen
One of the first key objectives for the Allied Forces after landing in Normandy on D-Day, 6 June 1944 was a place called Caen. The first bombardment of the French city began at 13.30 on D-Day, and it continued from one side or the other throughout the whole of June and July.
Obeisance
Respect, honour, worship.

Subjects

PDF Download

Please click on "Print view" at the top of the page to see a print friendly version of the article.