Messi and Ronaldo out as knockouts start

Devastation: Neither Messi nor Ronaldo has scored a goal in a World Cup knockout match.

Can either Messi or Ronaldo be called the best player of all time? Both Argentina and Portugal crashed out Saturday, meaning both players are unlikely to ever get their hands on a World Cup medal.

In a matter of hours, football’s two biggest stars crashed out of the World Cup on Saturday. Lionel Messi’s Argentina were felled by France, while Cristiano Ronaldo’s Portugal lost to Uruguay.

This may have been the last chance for either to win the World Cup.

By the time the next World Cup is held in 2022, Messi will be 35 and Ronaldo will be 38. If they do play, both would be well into the twilight of their careers.

Football has never seen a duopoly like Messi and Ronaldo. Between them they have hogged the last 10 Ballon d’Ors, each winning five. Both are seriously talked about as being the greatest players ever.

But, unless something extraordinary happens in 2022, both will have one terrible blot on their career: no World Cup win.

This is in contrast to the pair’s two most obvious competitors for the title of best footballer of all time, Pelé and Maradona.

Pelé burst onto the scene as a 17-year-old when Brazil won the 1958 World Cup. He won it again in 1970. Fast-forward 16 years to Mexico ‘86, where Diego Maradona almost single-handedly hauled Argentina to the title.

Messi and Ronaldo’s club careers are filled with memorable moments. But do their World Cup woes detract from their greatness?

Unfinished business

Of course not, say some. Your failures shouldn’t define you. Football is a team game: Pelé and Maradona were surrounded by other stars. And the World Cup has been eclipsed by the Champions League as football’s elite competition. Messi and Ronaldo have thrived there. Forget their World Cup misfortune.

Wrong, say others. The World Cup remains the pinnacle of the game. You simply have to turn up when it matters. At the peak of any field it is tiny differences that separate the very best from the rest. Messi and Ronaldo must be held responsible for their failure here. It is a blot on their careers.

You Decide

  1. Who is better: Lionel Messi or Cristiano Ronaldo?


  1. Class debate: “This house believes it is pointless to compare players from two utterly different eras.”
  2. Think of a major historical figure whose life or career ended in defeat. To what extent does it tarnish his or her legacy?

Some People Say...

“You have to show up in the World Cup, and in the World Cup anything can happen.”

Lionel Messi

What do you think?

Q & A

What do we know?
Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo are out of the World Cup. Argentina lost 4-3 to France while Portugal lost 2-1 to Uruguay.
What do we not know?
Just who is the greatest player of all time. It is incredibly hard to compare Pelé, who spent most of his career playing in Brazil in the 1960s, to someone who plays at the top level of European football today.

Word Watch

He would be far from the oldest player to appear at the World Cup. That record is held by Egypt’s goalkeeper Essam El-Hadary, who played at this World Cup at the age of 45.
The last 10 Ballon d’Ors
Messi won it in 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2015; Ronaldo in 2008, 2013, 2014, 2016 and 2017.
No World Cup win
Ronaldo has won the European Championships, while Messi has never won a senior international honour.
The Brazil team of the 1970 World Cup is generally agreed to have been the greatest international team of all time.

PDF Download

Please click on "Print view" at the top of the page to see a print friendly version of the article.