China shuts down as new virus goes global

Trapped: At least 10 people on board a cruiser in the Japanese port of Yokohama have tested positive.

Can the coronavirus be contained? As the number of infected rises, the world is racing to isolate the disease and prevent a global pandemic. But some experts believe it is already too late.

Borders closed, roads blocked, flights cancelled.

The biggest operation in history to contain an infectious disease is happening right now in Hubei province, in central China. Over 50 million people are quarantined, banned from leaving the region.

Two numbers help us understand what is happening. The first is the case mortality rate. This tells us what percentage of the people infected will die.

The WHO currently estimates the virus is killing 2.1% of those with the virus, mostly the elderly and people with other health problems. That is higher than flu (less than 0.1%), but is not as deadly as the Sars outbreak of 2003 (9.5%).

The second number is the infection rate. How many people does each person infect, on average? It may be as low as 1.4 people, but scientists think it could be as high as 5.5. Much less contagious than measles (12 to 18 people), but much more than Sars.

One more piece of the puzzle: the virus takes up to two weeks to incubate in the body before you begin to feel ill. This is why the Chinese government has quarantined millions of healthy people in Hubei.

But containment may make things worse, says public health expert Vageesh Jain. “A quarantine of this scale will create more problems than it solves.” Shutting down whole cities will cause food shortages and spread panic.

Can it be contained?

Stick or twist

Yes, because it has to be. Firstly, even if containment reduces the spread by as little as 10% or 5%, it is still worth it. Secondly, the idea is to buy time while scientists rush to try and develop a vaccine. Thirdly, it is easier to focus medical resources on fewer areas.

No. Quarantine only works with smaller numbers. And like any virus, this one will eventually peak and then fall away. And next time it strikes, humanity will be ready with a vaccine.

You Decide

  1. Have you ever received a chain letter? Do you think that a virus spreads in a similar way?


  1. You’re going into quarantine with your family. List five things you will take with you.

Some People Say...

“Only one form of contagion travels faster than a virus. And that’s fear.”

Dan Brown, American novelist

What do you think?

Q & A

What do we know?
It is widely agreed that an epidemic follows a recognised pattern. At first, the number of cases increases rapidly until the proportion of vulnerable people (like the elderly, who could still catch the disease) starts dropping in relation to the number of immune people (who’ve had the disease and recovered, or who’ve had a vaccine). At a certain point. the amount of cases drops – eventually leading to extinction of the infection.
What do we not know?
Most crucially, there is much disagreement about how best to hasten the death of a virus. One way is to let the virus spread freely. Parents used to take their children to “measles parties” in order for them to catch the disease early and become immune. It depends how deadly a virus really is and how fast it spreads. We are still guessing at the variables that will determine when the new coronavirus will peak and how many total deaths that will involve.

Word Watch

Isolating the infected from the rest of the public is probably the oldest technique for managing an epidemic. It’s mentioned in the Bible to stop leprosy and was used in the 14th Century against the Black Death.
Case mortality rate
The number of deaths in a population. Compare these figures to malaria (over 200 million cases each year and 400,000 deaths) and tuberculosis (10 million cases and 1.3 million deaths).
The World Health Organisation is the part of the United Nations responsible for public health around the world.
Severe acute respiratory syndrome was another form of coronavirus that developed in 2002-2003 in southern China. It infected 8,098 people in 17 countries and the final death toll was 774.
Infection rate
The average number of people infected by one case.

PDF Download

Please click on "Print view" at the top of the page to see a print friendly version of the article.