A diesel-driving, meat-eating climate minister

Balanced diet: MP Claire Perry says her typical family meal is a meat and vegetable stir-fry.

Is she a hypocrite? Britain’s climate minister, Claire Perry, has come under fire for refusing to encourage eco-friendly diets. A meat-eater herself, she also admitted to driving a diesel car.

The clock is ticking. Scientists say we only have 12 years to save the world from the catastrophic impacts of climate change, and many claim that adopting a meat-free diet is the biggest way an individual can help.

However, this opinion is not shared by MP Claire Perry. Minister for Energy and Clean Growth, she is responsible for Britain’s fight against global warming.

"I like lots of local meat,” she told BBC News this week: “I don’t think we should be in the business of prescribing to people how they should run their diets.”

Craig Bennett from Friends of the Earth swiftly accused her of a “dereliction of duty”.

In a report released last week, scientists claimed that huge reductions in meat-eating are necessary to avoid climate breakdown. Britons must cut their beef consumption by 90%, it claims.

Meat and dairy production causes 14.5% of global CO2 emissions — more than all the world’s transport. If everyone gave up it up, global farmland use could be reduced by over 75% — an area equivalent to the US, China, European Union and Australia combined.

Yesterday, Perry also admitted to driving a diesel car despite their bad environmental reputation.

Is she a hypocrite?

No to eco

Of course, some argue. Perry is in charge of leading Britain’s fight against climate change and she has a duty to set an example. The behaviour of individuals will make a decisive impact on the climate crisis. Our leaders must not shy away from making controversial statements on diet.

Not necessarily, others respond. Ultimately, technological advances could make a bigger impact than dietary choices. Furthermore, people do not necessarily need to give up meat; cutting down makes a difference too. Spreading aggressive messages of abstinence will only turn people away from environmentalism altogether.

You Decide

  1. Should everyone give up meat to help the environment?

Activities

  1. In one minute write down all the ways that young people can help the environment. Discuss your ideas with the class. Which three ideas would be the most effective? Would politicians be able to encourage everyone to do these things? Why/why not?

Some People Say...

“Practically every environmental problem we have can be traced to our addiction to fossil fuels.”

Dennis Weaver

What do you think?

Q & A

What do we know?
Claire Perry made these comments as she launched Green GB Week, which aims to show how the UK can simultaneously boost the economy and cut emissions.
What do we not know?
Experts have warned that “unprecedented” action is needed by all governments to stop catastrophic levels of warming. We do not know if the measures politicians will undertake will be enough.

Word Watch

12 years
According to a landmark Unite Nations report released last week.
Friends of the Earth
Founded in 1969 as an anti-nuclear group, the organisation is now primarily associated with environmental campaigns.
Report
Research led by Marco Springmann of Oxford University.
14.5%
According to the Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations. By contrast, transport accounts for 14% of global emissions.
75%
As reported in the paper “Reducing food’s environmental impacts through producers and consumers,” by Joseph Poore.

PDF Download

Please click on "Print view" at the top of the page to see a print friendly version of the article.