Do we have a moral duty to help refugees? As millions await the lavish treats of Christmas, others are freezing in rubbish-strewn shanty camps. Or is it more complex than that?
Squalid camps that shame the Western world
Do we have a moral duty to help refugees? As millions await the lavish treats of Christmas, others are freezing in rubbish-strewn shanty camps. Or is it more complex than that?
"We die. Doesn't matter." These were the words of a refugee in the forests that separate Poland from BelarusBelarus is an eastern European state that is a close ally of Russia. Run by Alexander Lukashenko, it is known as "the last dictatorship in Europe".. The borders of the EU are becoming a fortress, with high fences and armed guards. Yet here, thousands of refugees are gathering to try to force their way in.
Critics claim that Alexander Lukashenko has manufactured this crisis by offering desperate people in Iraq and Syria tourist visas, and then helping them make their way into the EU states on his border: Poland, Lithuania and LatviaLike Lithuania, Latvia is a Baltic country formerly part of the USSR which today is one of the easternmost members of the EU.. They argue he is using the refugees to punish the EU for sanctions.
Regardless of the cause, the human cost is beyond doubt. In November, temperatures in Belarus drop to 1.4C. By December it will be -5.5C at night.
Many of the refugees are living in shelters they built from branches. They may freeze to death.
The migrant crisis has struck the heart of Europe. Yesterday it was the turn of Britain and France to get into a war of words over who is responsible for stopping refugees crossing the Channel. At least 300 people are thought to have died making this journey.
Across the western world people are preparing for Christmas. It is estimated that in the UK, 130 million sprouts, 74 million mince pies and 4.2 million plates of turkey will be thrown away.
That is why some wonder how the West can tolerate this inequality. They think it needs to take responsibility for refugees.
They point out that Europe has not even taken on the burden of processing and supporting the refugees who are making for their shores, instead relying on poorer countries to bear the brunt. Lebanon now hosts 1.7 million refugees, mostly fleeing from the civil war in SyriaIn 2011, parts of the Syrian population rose up against dictator Bashar al-Assad. The fighting has displaced around 13.5 million Syrians, of whom 6.8 million have fled the country..
They point out western power has played a role in creating these streams of people. Most of the people gathering in Belarus are Kurds from northern Iraq, who have suffered under US occupation.
The chaotic Nato withdrawal from AfghanistanIn late August, the Nato forces that had been posted in Afghanistan for 20 years withdrew from the country. They were criticised for leaving behind interpreters and other local allies. is likely to create more refugees in the coming months. Many of those trying to cross the Channel are fleeing poverty, coming from countries that are straining under debt and the effects of climate breakdown.
Others think this attitude is patronising. They say the most heartfelt wish of any refugee is to return to their home. Taking refugees in will not give them a better life: it just means keeping them in limboA phrase meaning "in a state of uncertainty". It comes from the Christian idea of Limbo, a temporary afterlife for people who are waiting to be redeemed by Christ.. We should work on improving conditions in their countries.
Do we have a moral duty to help refugees?
Yes. It is grotesque that people in the West are throwing away so much food while others are starving. It is the western world that has created the conditions people around the world are fleeing, and it is their duty to help.
No. They argue it is not sustainable to encourage everyone to come to the West. It is not a kindness to bring refugees into Europe, keep them living in low-quality accommodation on a stipendA fixed, regular sum of money paid to a person to support their living costs., while doing nothing to help them return to their homes.
Keywords
Belarus - Belarus is an eastern European state that is a close ally of Russia. Run by Alexander Lukashenko, it is known as "the last dictatorship in Europe".
Latvia - Like Lithuania, Latvia is a Baltic country formerly part of the USSR which today is one of the easternmost members of the EU.
Civil war in Syria - In 2011, parts of the Syrian population rose up against dictator Bashar al-Assad. The fighting has displaced around 13.5 million Syrians, of whom 6.8 million have fled the country.
Withdrawal from Afghanistan - In late August, the Nato forces that had been posted in Afghanistan for 20 years withdrew from the country. They were criticised for leaving behind interpreters and other local allies.
In limbo - A phrase meaning "in a state of uncertainty". It comes from the Christian idea of Limbo, a temporary afterlife for people who are waiting to be redeemed by Christ.
Stipend - A fixed, regular sum of money paid to a person to support their living costs.
Squalid camps that shame the Western world
Glossary
Belarus - Belarus is an eastern European state that is a close ally of Russia. Run by Alexander Lukashenko, it is known as “the last dictatorship in Europe”.
Latvia - Like Lithuania, Latvia is a Baltic country formerly part of the USSR which today is one of the easternmost members of the EU.
Civil war in Syria - In 2011, parts of the Syrian population rose up against dictator Bashar al-Assad. The fighting has displaced around 13.5 million Syrians, of whom 6.8 million have fled the country.
Withdrawal from Afghanistan - In late August, the Nato forces that had been posted in Afghanistan for 20 years withdrew from the country. They were criticised for leaving behind interpreters and other local allies.
In limbo - A phrase meaning “in a state of uncertainty”. It comes from the Christian idea of Limbo, a temporary afterlife for people who are waiting to be redeemed by Christ.
Stipend - A fixed, regular sum of money paid to a person to support their living costs.