Is this sensible? If you are lost, getting found is obviously a good thing. When it comes to humanity broadcasting a message to aliens, the answer is much less clear-cut.
Scientists send aliens a bold new message
Is this sensible? If you are lost, getting found is obviously a good thing. When it comes to humanity broadcasting a message to aliens, the answer is much less clear-cut.
Scientists have devised a new message in the search for extraterrestrial life, the Beacon in the Galaxy (BITG), which will soon be beamed into space.
It contains digital images of humans, along with information about life on Earth and the location of our solar system. And it invites any sentient being that finds it to respond.
This is not the first time we have tried to contact aliens. In 1974, a coded radio message with some of the same information was emitted from the Arecibo ObservatoryAn observatory in Puerto Rico. Its telescope was the largest single-aperture telescope in the world from 1963 until 2016. It collapsed in 2020..
In 1977, the two Voyager spacecraftTwo interstellar probes launched in 1977 towards Jupiter and Saturn. They transmit information back to Earth but can never be brought back, so they will spend the rest of eternity traversing the universe. sent to study the planets of the outer solar system were fitted with "Golden RecordsTwo gold-coloured vinyl-style records mounted on the Voyager spacecraft that play sounds on one side and feature diagrams and images on the other. They have been compared with a message in a bottle. ", which store a variety of natural sounds, greetings in 55 languages and diagrams and written messages.
Neither of these represented serious efforts at contact. The Golden Records are not due to pass another star for 40,000 years.
The BITG, in contrast, is being beamed directly at the part of space where we think it is most likely we will find life.
Physicist Michio KakuAn American theoretical physicist and public scientist. has compared us with the AztecsThe most powerful Central American civilisation in 1492, when Europeans first made sustained contact with the Americans. Their civilisation was destroyed by the Spanish, who enslaved what was left of their people., warning that aliens may wipe us out.
Scientists have to overcome another problem: how can we make ourselves understood?
We communicate with others via "language games" that give our words meaning.
For example, if someone shouts "Water!", this might mean they have found an oasis after weeks in the desert, or that there is a fire that must be put out. It could be a warning that some water is poisoned - or even a secret code. We cannot know for sure without using the "rules" of ordinary language.
This mostly works amongst human beings because these language games are familiar to us: we can instinctively work out from our context what "game" we are playing. But aliens would have completely different points of reference. Like lions, they might be unable to take part in the same language games as us, leaving us incapable of communicating.
Scientists hope to get around this with maths. They are transmitting the BITG in binary codeText made up entirely of two symbols, usually 0 and 1., along with some basic mathematical concepts to establish terms of communication they hope will be universal. But if the aliens have a different understanding of physics, this could still fail.
It might be that we have no idea what we are actually telling them. Or it could be that we are telling them more than we realise.
Is this sensible?
Yes: There are probably aliens elsewhere in the galaxy. As such, we should make it clear that we want peace and communication. That way, they are less likely to attack.
No: There is no way of stating our intentions clearly to a civilisation that might have no means of understanding us. The BITG is nothing more than an invitation to come and conquer the Earth.
Or...? The BITG is probably just a waste of time. The chances of it actually reaching an alien civilisation are minuscule, and unless their technology is far more advance than our own they will struggle to return an answer.
Keywords
Arecibo Observatory - An observatory in Puerto Rico. Its telescope was the largest single-aperture telescope in the world from 1963 until 2016. It collapsed in 2020.
Voyager spacecraft - Two interstellar probes launched in 1977 towards Jupiter and Saturn. They transmit information back to Earth but can never be brought back, so they will spend the rest of eternity traversing the universe.
Golden Records - Two gold-coloured vinyl-style records mounted on the Voyager spacecraft that play sounds on one side and feature diagrams and images on the other. They have been compared with a message in a bottle.
Michio Kaku - An American theoretical physicist and public scientist.
Aztecs - The most powerful Central American civilisation in 1492, when Europeans first made sustained contact with the Americans. Their civilisation was destroyed by the Spanish, who enslaved what was left of their people.
Binary code - Text made up entirely of two symbols, usually 0 and 1.
Scientists send aliens a bold new message
Glossary
Arecibo Observatory - An observatory in Puerto Rico. Its telescope was the largest single-aperture telescope in the world from 1963 until 2016. It collapsed in 2020.
Voyager spacecraft - Two interstellar probes launched in 1977 towards Jupiter and Saturn. They transmit information back to Earth but can never be brought back, so they will spend the rest of eternity traversing the universe.
Golden Records - Two gold-coloured vinyl-style records mounted on the Voyager spacecraft that play sounds on one side and feature diagrams and images on the other. They have been compared with a message in a bottle.
Michio Kaku - An American theoretical physicist and public scientist.
Aztecs - The most powerful Central American civilisation in 1492, when Europeans first made sustained contact with the Americans. Their civilisation was destroyed by the Spanish, who enslaved what was left of their people.
Binary code - Text made up entirely of two symbols, usually 0 and 1.