Can a person ever change their character? The British prime minister has promised to turn over a new leaf. Again. Like most of us, he believes he can change – but probably won’t. In 2004, Boris Johnson was sacked as Shadow Arts Minister for lying about having an affair. "Boris is finished", observers confidently predicted. Yet just four years later, he got himself elected Mayor of London. In 2016, he was seen as the frontrunner to become the new prime minister. But he had to pull out of the contest after key ally Michael Gove turned on him. "Boris is finished", observers said again. Instead, he was appointed Foreign Secretary. He lasted two years before resigning so he could criticise his own government’s negotiations with the EU. "This time", they said, "he really is finished". Yet in 2019, he was elected prime minister. Barnard Castle, Owen Paterson, Partygate – any other prime minister would have fallen long ago. Yet last night, faced with a confidence vote from his own MPs, Johnson has once again lived to tell the tale. He promised his furious MPs that if they voted to keep him, he would change how he operates. But his way of doing politics has raised him to the highest office in the land. So why, some ask, would he ever change? In fact, some think no politician ever changes. In 1837, Benjamin Disraeli made his maiden speech in the House of Commons. Other MPs mocked his pompous speaking style until he sat down, humiliated. Two decades later, he was prime minister. He would dominate British politics for the next 10 years – making exactly the same flamboyant addresses. But some politicians have changed their ways. In the 1960s, George Wallace, Governor of Alabama, was a staunch segregationist who ran openly racist campaigns. But in the late 1970s, he renounced his past views and apologised to Black civil rights leaders. He appointed a record number of Black people to state positions. Can a person ever change their character? All change please Yes: Many politicians undergo a Damascene conversion in their time. Some even end up switching parties, or dismantling their own legacy. We should never give up hope of change. No: The public does not like its politicians to change too much. Michael Portillo went from hardline conservative to social liberal, and it ended his career. From another viewpoint, change looks like inconsistency or cowardice. Or… Politicians change in small ways all the time. Johnson himself has morphed from a liberal Mayor of London into an authoritarian prime minister. But big shifts in their character are much rarer. KeywordsMichael Gove - A Conservative politician who has held a variety of high-profile ministerial positions. He was defeated by Theresa May in the 2016 Conservative leadership election.
Can a person ever change their character?
Keywords
Michael Gove - A Conservative politician who has held a variety of high-profile ministerial positions. He was defeated by Theresa May in the 2016 Conservative leadership election.
Barnard Castle - In 2020, Boris Johnson's chief advisor, Dominic Cummings, sparked controversy when it emerged that he had visited Barnard Castle in Durham at the height of the first Covid-19 lockdown. Johnson defended Cummings, who later left the government and became a critic of his former boss.
Owen Paterson - In November 2021, senior MP Owen Paterson was found to have broken paid advocacy rules. Johnson defended him and tried to change the rules in his favour. In the resultant outcry, Paterson had to resign and his seat was won by the Liberal Democrats.
Benjamin Disraeli - A 19th-Century politician who was Britain's first and only prime minister of Jewish origin.
Alabama - A state in the southern USA. It had one of the largest slave populations before the Civil War, and afterwards, it imposed harsh Jim Crow laws to disenfranchise Black Americans.
‘Greased piglet’ Johnson survives (for now)
Glossary
Michael Gove - A Conservative politician who has held a variety of high-profile ministerial positions. He was defeated by Theresa May in the 2016 Conservative leadership election.
Barnard Castle - In 2020, Boris Johnson’s chief advisor, Dominic Cummings, sparked controversy when it emerged that he had visited Barnard Castle in Durham at the height of the first Covid-19 lockdown. Johnson defended Cummings, who later left the government and became a critic of his former boss.
Owen Paterson - In November 2021, senior MP Owen Paterson was found to have broken paid advocacy rules. Johnson defended him and tried to change the rules in his favour. In the resultant outcry, Paterson had to resign and his seat was won by the Liberal Democrats.
Benjamin Disraeli - A 19th-Century politician who was Britain’s first and only prime minister of Jewish origin.
Alabama - A state in the southern USA. It had one of the largest slave populations before the Civil War, and afterwards, it imposed harsh Jim Crow laws to disenfranchise Black Americans.