Are fireworks a waste of money? It may seem wrong that we burn millions of dollars for a fleeting moment of glory. But there is also a serious moral defence for extravagance.
Fireworks glory as millions go up in smoke
Are fireworks a waste of money? It may seem wrong that we burn millions of dollars for a fleeting moment of glory. But there is also a serious moral defence for extravagance.
Last night, the skies above the world's great cities exploded into colour. From Delhi to Dubai, London to New York, fireworks were hurled into the air to celebrate DiwaliA five-day festival. It celebrates different events in the history of each of the participating religions..
Nicknamed the "festival of light", Diwali is shared by Hindus, Sikhs, JainsFollowers of Jainism, an ancient Indian religion whose followers live a life of non-violence and non-attachment to worldly possessions. and some Buddhists. PyrotechnicsThe craft of creating and using fireworks and other similar devices. The word is sometimes used to stand in for fireworks. is a common feature. In India, approximately ₹50 billion (£495m) is spent on fireworks each year.
This week, for the first time since 2018, Diwali's biggest evening occurred the day before Britain's Bonfire NightAn annual commemoration of the 1605 Gunpowder Plot that attempted to blow up the Houses of Parliament. By the end of the 17th Century, fireworks were a common feature.. This adds another £500m of fireworks.
Fireworks are popular almost everywhere. An eye-watering amount of money changes hands for them. The US spent a record $2bn in 2020 on 15,600 fireworks.
Few would argue that this is the most useful way to spend this money. $2bn could get you 100m doses of the Pfizer Covid-19 vaccine.
Shooting fireworks does nothing for the crises facing humans - indeed, it actively pollutes. Yet we continue to buy them, quite literally burning money.
In this we follow our ancestors. The earliest known fireworks date from 800 AD. Chinese alchemists used them to scare away evil spirits. They were later used as weapons.
In 1295, Marco PoloVenetian Explorer (1254 - 1324) who travelled from Italy to East Asia and back. His account of his travels gave Europeans their first accurate look at the culture of many Asian countries. brought fireworks back to Europe, where they became immensely popular as a centrepiece of lavish entertainments such as the Field of the Cloth of Gold. Russian tsar Peter the GreatModernising Russian tsar (1672 - 1725). As well as fireworks, Peter was fond of fountains and cruel practical jokes, sometimes in combination. was moved to say: "My great passions are navigation and fireworks." They remain key to big celebrations, from US Independence Day to Olympics opening ceremonies.
Some of humanity's greatest achievements are characterised by similar excess. If the Mughal emperorThe Mughal Empire ruled much of present-day India, Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh between the 16th and 19th Centuries. Shah Jahan had built his wife a conventional tomb, we would not have the Taj Mahal. Medieval cathedrals shine through their artistic magnificence.
In King Lear, Shakespeare's doomed protagonist says: "Allow not nature more than nature needs, / Man's life's as cheap as beast's." We are nothing more than animals if we only live for life's essentials. It is the pleasures, however big or small, which make life worth living.
Some philosophers offer support for this view. Ethical hedonists believe we should seek pleasure. A long and healthy but asceticSomeone who absents themselves from worldly pleasures. life is nothing to one that burns brightly.
Not everyone agrees. A glittering garment or a firework display might give people a moment of joy. But for those facing hardships, it is a distraction. Ending the pain that stands in the way of pleasure should come first.
Are fireworks a waste of money?
Yes. The ancient physician Hippocrates wrote: "Everything in excess is opposed to nature". He was referring to the human body. But his idea is a manta to live by. Extravagances are unnatural. And nothing could be more extravagant than fireworks.
No. Greek philosopher Aristippus of Cyrene argued that pleasure was the highest form of truth. We access our strongest feelings and finest thoughts when confronted with beauty. And few things can arouse such happiness as much as the astounding thrill of pyrotechnics.
Keywords
Diwali - A five-day festival. It celebrates different events in the history of each of the participating religions.
Jains - Followers of Jainism, an ancient Indian religion whose followers live a life of non-violence and non-attachment to worldly possessions.
Pyrotechnics - The craft of creating and using fireworks and other similar devices. The word is sometimes used to stand in for fireworks.
Bonfire Night - An annual commemoration of the 1605 Gunpowder Plot that attempted to blow up the Houses of Parliament. By the end of the 17th Century, fireworks were a common feature.
Marco Polo - Venetian Explorer (1254 - 1324) who travelled from Italy to East Asia and back. His account of his travels gave Europeans their first accurate look at the culture of many Asian countries.
Peter the Great - Modernising Russian tsar (1672 - 1725). As well as fireworks, Peter was fond of fountains and cruel practical jokes, sometimes in combination.
Mughal emperor - The Mughal Empire ruled much of present-day India, Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh between the 16th and 19th Centuries.
Ascetic - Someone who absents themselves from worldly pleasures.
Fireworks glory as millions go up in smoke
Glossary
Diwali - A five-day festival. It celebrates different events in the history of each of the participating religions.
Jains - Followers of Jainism, an ancient Indian religion whose followers live a life of non-violence and non-attachment to worldly possessions.
Pyrotechnics - The craft of creating and using fireworks and other similar devices. The word is sometimes used to stand in for fireworks.
Bonfire Night - An annual commemoration of the 1605 Gunpowder Plot that attempted to blow up the Houses of Parliament. By the end of the 17th Century, fireworks were a common feature.
Marco Polo - Venetian Explorer (1254 - 1324) who travelled from Italy to East Asia and back. His account of his travels gave Europeans their first accurate look at the culture of many Asian countries.
Peter the Great - Modernising Russian tsar (1672 - 1725). As well as fireworks, Peter was fond of fountains and cruel practical jokes, sometimes in combination.
Mughal emperor - The Mughal Empire ruled much of present-day India, Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh between the 16th and 19th Centuries.
Ascetic - Someone who absents themselves from worldly pleasures.